"Everybody's a Critic" concerns the frustrations of a film school dropout and a stranger that meet in a bar, and begin to discuss the canon of great American Cinema. As the movie references begin to fly and their opinions begin to differ, their discussion becomes more existential and a dangerous anger bubbles to the surface that threatens to destroy one of them. Or maybe not. In turns both philosophical and funny, “Everybody's a Critic” explores the question of why we are drawn to stories of inaction and ineptitude, not only in our entertainment, but also in our own lives.